P@SHA Warns NCCIA Raids Threaten Record $4.6 Billion IT Exports and Calls for Warrants, Verification and a Joint Cell

Pasha Warns NCCIA Raids

Pakistan’s main IT industry body has asked the National Cyber Crime Investigation Agency (NCCIA) to stop treating legitimate software and call centre companies as scam operations, saying a growing number of raids on registered firms is putting the country’s record IT exports at risk. The Pakistan Software Houses Association for IT and ITES (P@SHA) made the call in a statement on Monday, as the agency continues the largest crackdown on scam call centres the country has seen.

P@SHA said it had serious concerns about a rising number of NCCIA raids on legitimate software and IT-enabled services companies and urged the agency to distinguish between genuine call centres and fraudulent ones. In the association’s view, call centres are legitimate businesses and scam centres are not call centres. According to the statement, member companies reported that NCCIA teams entered their offices without presenting warrants, detained and questioned employees for hours, and took laptops, servers and phones into custody even where no wrongdoing was found. The association stressed that scam centres defraud people in Pakistan and abroad, damage the country’s reputation and directly harm legitimate IT exporters, and said the industry fully supports every lawful, evidence-based operation against them.

The statement also acknowledged an uncomfortable fact: the NCCIA has itself said some fraud operators register their businesses as IT companies. For that reason, P@SHA argued, enforcement must differentiate carefully between the two instead of treating every office with laptops and a night shift as a suspect. It proposed that the agency verify a company’s status with the Pakistan Software Export Board (PSEB) and P@SHA through a designated focal person available around the clock before any raid, and that it avoid conducting media trials of IT-related firms. The association also proposed a standing committee of the NCCIA, the Ministry of IT and Telecommunication, PSEB and P@SHA to review complaints, share intelligence about scam operators and agree on procedures for raids on registered IT companies. NextUp News reported that the group has asked for an urgent joint meeting with the IT minister, the Interior Ministry and the NCCIA chief.

The warning carries weight because of what is at stake. IT exports reached a record $4.6 billion in the last fiscal year, up from $3.8 billion the year before, according to Dawn’s report on the statement. The sector is one of the few areas of the economy that has been growing quickly, and its reputation with foreign clients depends on predictability and security. A raid that disrupts a registered company, even if it turns out to be mistaken, can cost it contracts and damage its relationships with overseas customers.

The NCCIA’s own figures show the scale of the effort. According to ARY News, the agency received 10,386 cybercrime complaints in 53 days and recovered more than Rs149.8 million in various operations. In that period, it conducted 59 raids on illegal call centres, registered 43 cases and arrested 973 suspects, including 211 foreign nationals, and its Cyber Patrolling Unit referred 1,186 illegal web links to the Pakistan Telecommunication Authority for blocking. NCCIA Additional Director Shahzad Akbar told ARY last week that around 300 to 350 skimming and scam call centres were operating in Karachi, and that the agency had decided not to give any concession to those involved. He added that young people who should be receiving an education were being employed in these centres and that local residents and retired people had also been targeted.

Also Read: NCCIA Says 350 Scam Call Centres Operate in Karachi, and One Just Got 273 People Arrested

The two accounts are not necessarily in conflict. The agency has real cases, including a Karachi raid last week in which 273 people were arrested and which a court dealt with by granting bail to women and minors, and the industry body agrees that scam operations must be stopped. The dispute is about method and verification: how the agency decides which premises to raid, what evidence it needs, and what happens to the legitimate companies and employees who are caught in the net. P@SHA’s allegation of warrantless entry is a serious one, and the coverage reviewed does not include an NCCIA response to it.

The agency’s own history adds context. In November 2025, reports said the Federal Investigation Agency registered a case against NCCIA officers accused of taking bribes from illegal call centres, according to Tribune and ProPakistani at the time. That episode showed that scam operators can seek protection from enforcers as well as hide among legitimate firms, and it strengthens the argument for clear, transparent procedures that can be checked by someone outside the agency. A verification mechanism with the regulator and the industry body could serve that purpose, as long as it does not become a delay that lets real scammers avoid action.

Several questions will determine how the dispute develops. Will the NCCIA agree to the joint committee and a verification process, and what safeguards would prevent information from leaking to targets? Will it respond to the claim that raids took place without warrants? And how will the agency define a legitimate call centre when scam operations sometimes register as IT companies and employ young people who may not understand the nature of the work? For the sector, the answers matter as much as the raids do.

Compiled by the Weekly PK Business Desk.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.